Tuesday, November 26, 2013

Potty Training Is The 15th Circle Of Hell

You guys. YOU GUYS. The day that I have been waiting for for seven years, four months, and nineteen days has ARRIVED.

EVERYONE IN MY HOUSE IS OFFICIALLY OUT OF DIAPERS.

I want to marinate in a bathtub of champagne. Now that we no longer have to buy diapers, I can afford to.

I want to run screaming down the street wearing a cape made of our leftover diapers. I want to burn them in a garbage can while laughing maniacally and inhaling the toxic fumes. I want to scream and laugh and jump 50 feet in the air. I am going to flip off the billions of boxes of diapers when I pass them in Costco, then take our forty dollars and buy milk for the boys to spill on the floor and the seven-ton bag of carrots that we can't possibly go through before half of them go bad.

And we're not just saving money! I have no idea what I am going to do with all my new found free time. I should start a hobby!

But you don't care how happy I am about this. I know what you all really want.

You want the "secret." WHAT IS THE SECRET TO POTTY TRAINING A KID? 

I have it!

The secret is...

.......Drum roll.......

....There is no secret. There is no "right way." There is no guaranteed trick that will work for every kid. There are ten thousand tricks, and maybe one of them will work for your kid, maybe not. Ultimately, they have to be ready and capable.

Sorry. I know, I know. Fuck you, Elizabeth! First you're gloating that you're done with diapers forever, and now you're saying there is no secret to potty training a kid?! I HOPE YOUR TUBAL LIGATION FAILS!

Don't worry, it probably will. (UPDATE: It fucking DID.) Anyway, three kids, and three different things got them to potty train. Here they are, in case one of them might work for you. Take your pick. It's potty roulette! A grab bag of potty tricks!

Note: Mine are all boys. Girls are different, from what I hear. I really don't know.

ETHAN (The first kid)

Ethan refused to potty train. At three and a half, he was still in diapers. He was scared of the toilet, he was scared of letting go of the only thing in his entire world he actually had sole control over. We, being first time parents were at a loss as to what to do. 

We begged. We bribed. We demonstrated. We threatened (to take privileges away). We put Cheerios in the toilet for him to aim at. We drank, heavily. We kept changing his diapers. (And the diapers of our one-and-a-half-year-old.) We were so over it.

I talked with a friend who has a jillion kids and works with a jillion kids as a special-ed teacher. She said we had to go hard-core and just take his diapers away. She pointed out that he's old enough, he has control over it, he knows how to do it, he's exhibiting all the signs of being ready (hiding to poop, staying dry for several hours between pees, asking for his diaper to be changed- which means he understands what he did in it).

So we went hard core and told Ethan that he was not allowed to wear diapers anymore, except at night. It was brutal. He did not take well to that. 

He would sit on the potty and cry and refuse to go. I would sit with him and read him a book or sing to him or play toys with him in an effort to relax him enough to go, but he still refused and begged for diapers.

With the pediatrician's words echoing in my head Don't force him, he'll hold it and may get bladder infections or constipated, I was scared and starting to panic, but determined. Desperately, I offered him the option of peeing into the bathtub drain. He did it, but then off course, that's all he wanted to do. We told him he could do it a few more times, then he had to use the potty, no choice.

When he finally did pee in the toilet, you'd have thought he was a Grammy-winning rock star who had just cured cancer, the way we treated him. 

But he was still holding his poop. After two days, I told him that if he didn't poop in the potty, I was going to have to give him yucky, yucky, yucky medicine (a children's laxative) that would make the poop come out, whether he wanted it to or not. He still refused, so I gave him some and he took one drink of the juice I mixed it in and refused to drink anymore of it. I was pretty pissed. I told him that I was going to have to force him to drink it because he was not pooping and then, he gave up.

He finally went and from that day on, we had no more issues- during the day. Then he started holding his pee to go into his nighttime diaper and I told him that if he did that again, I was going to take away his nighttime diapers too. That got him to stop.

Five or so months later, we took away his nighttime diapers, too. We definitely waited too long to do that, but live and learn.

And today, at seven years old, he exhibits no trauma from having his precious diapers taken away. Maybe it will manifest itself later and he'll be one of those 40-year-olds who dress like babies and wear diapers as a fetish, but I'm not really worried about it.

Needless to say, potty training him was total hell. But he's made up for it by not having any accidents, except maybe one, and never wetting the bed.

CONNOR (The second kid)

Connor was so easy to train that I actually have little memory of it. He did exactly what we suspected (and hoped) he would do: Follow his big brother's example and just start doing it on his own. He wanted to do everything that his coveted big brother did, which included peeing and pooping in the potty.

We still had to cajole and encourage and bribe him a bit to get him to do it consistently, but it was way less angst-inducing than it was with Ethan. I didn't actually want to shoot myself in the face with him!

We can't remember exactly how old he was, but it was either just before he turned three or just after that he was officially out of diapers. We did do the nighttime diaper thing for another month or so, then stopped those and he's never wet the bed.

BRANDON (The third kid)

We mistakenly thought that Brandon, having not one but TWO older brothers to follow the example of and want to be like, would be even easier to train than Connor was.

AAAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA<------fake, soul-crushed laugh

The crazy thing is, he started peeing in the toilet right after he turned two. He was so short he had to stand on a step stool to even get his wang over the lip of the toilet (he didn't want to use a training potty) but the stool made him too tall and he had terrible, terrible aim and pissed everywhere, all the time.

And by doing this, the little effer got our hopes up. OH HEY! He's going to potty train EARLY! This is AWESOME!

No.

He continued to cocktease us with the potty training for another year. He'd pee in the toilet for a solid day, our hopes would get up, noooooope, the next day, the toilet was the devil in a smelly, piss-soaked white dress.

Then he'd pull three days of peeing in the toilet out of his hat. We'd treat him like an even better Grammy winning rock star who'd eradicated the flu and diabetes. Then, like a punch straight to the soul, he'd treat the toilet like it had Ebola and refuse to use it.

Then he'd poop in the toilet consistently, but stop peeing in it. It was one or the other. It was old. 

Now that he's three years and four months, I got kind of mad. He wasn't refusing to use or incapable of using the toilet, he was refusing to use it consistently

I took away his pull-ups, put on some undies, and very sternly told him not to pee or poop in them. I told him that he knows how and when to use the potty, and he needs to do it. I also threw in the "trouble" word. At this point, not using the potty was becoming an act of defiance.

And then I asked him about 5 times an hour if he had to go. Every 15th time or so, he'd say "yes!" and run to the bathroom. 

This has been going on for nine days now, with one pee (thankfully, not poop) accident. We still put a nighttime diaper on at night, but that's only going to happen for another month or so, tops.


So, with that, I say,


And, to you warriors still fighting this battle, hang in there. It WILL happen for you and your kids. Promise.

For those who have fought and won, what worked for you and your kid(s)? Put your tips in the comments!




Join in the fun on Facebook and Twitter!

Comments (23)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Yay!!!!!!!!!!

For my oldest, Ethan, what worked best for me was waiting until he turned 3, and for him it was easy peasy. He had been using the potty, but not consistently, so I decided to give it a real shot. Diapers off, we were not leaving the house all day. So, he had one day of peeing all over ,all day loooong, a few times in the toilet, though; then he woke up the next day and didn't have one (peeing) accident, it was like it just clicked. Three days later and he had pooping down as well. At 3 yrs one week old, he never looked back.

Now for my youngest, Jasper, he decided to start using the potty about 3wks ago (@ 2yrs 1 month). He hasn't shit in a diaper since, stays dry all night, and maybe has 1-2 pee accident a day (some days none). As for now, I am just going with the flow and I am just counting my blessings that the diaper usage has gone down. I am not pushing him, but I do ask him if he has to go whenever I have to or we are leaving the house.

Now the day that I am done wiping butts....oh that day....that day I will shout from the rooftops!
1 reply · active 592 weeks ago
Yay! I love reading that other moms had it a bit easier... I wouldn't wish that angst on anyone!

Dude, yeah, definitely celebrating the no more butt wiping for SURE!
Both my boys hit the milestone during summer months. They loved to "water" the flowers. Dont judge it worked with no struggles.
1 reply · active 592 weeks ago
Awesome! Hey, no judging here!
My son is just shy of 2 years old- and he stays dry most nights, is very curious about it when we go to the bathroom. Especially his dad, I make my husband leave the bathroom door open when he goes pee now and my husband HATES it haha- and my son will take off his diaper and throw it away if there is poop in it. He also will use a wipe to clean his wang and will (rarely) fetch a new diaper for me to put on him.

I'm not rushing the potty training on him, the child doesn't talk, so asking him 239047845976 times a day if he has to pee or poop will be maddening and I don't know what he wants when he cries anyway, so I'm going to hold off a little longer. When he starts saying some words then I will consider it. I'm a bit annoyed about the talking thing, obviously. I know he can understand what we say to him as he follows directions relatively well for a toddler... just I know he will when he is ready. But whether or not I stab myself in the face before then... it's a toss up
My recent post Accomplished
1 reply · active 592 weeks ago
It's so good though that he's showing signs early! Good luck with it all when you guys get there!
Mazel tov! We did a combination of boot camp and bribery. Did you teach them all to pee standing up? We taught my boy to pee sitting down at first (at two and a half). My husband finally put his foot down at three and a half and transitioned him to standing. I miss sitting. You don't have to worry about aim when they sit.
My recent post I Quit Thanksgiving
2 replies · active 592 weeks ago
After seeing the mess, I tried to transition #3 to sitting but he refused for the LONGEST time. Now, he'll do both. I'm always happy when he sits, but yeah, I get your husband's desire to get yours to stand!
My husband will actually sit to go most times. He says it makes it easier for married life haha not that he has bad aim, but no matter how good their aim is, it is a spray... ugh... Who started this whole standing up to pee thing anyway?
My recent post Accomplished
My oldest, Charlie, was potty trained on his 3rd birthday. My mom came up early to help set up the party and she helped(forced) me to get started. He put him in underwear and set the timer for 15 minutes, every time it went off I asked him if he needed to go. The only two or three times he had accidents is when I go tired of asking him to go. He had said "No" the last two times so I wouldn't ask him the next time the timer went off, 5 minutes later he would pee his pants. He did have one poop accident that day but luckily for us he HATES to get dirty so he pooped once, had to waddle to through the house to the bathroom and never did it again! He did the timer thing the rest of the weekend, daycare kept it up the next couple days and we never looked back. We kept the pull-ups for awhile longer then threw those out too. He does pee standing, the daycare had toddler sized urinals and we have never had a problem with aim. He can also hold his pee longer than anybody I have ever met! He can go 4-6 hours without peeing, most mornings I have to force him in to go. No UTIs yet though.
1 reply · active 592 weeks ago
Yay for no UTIs! Man, I wish I could have installed toddler-sized urinals in my house...
Congratulations!! That is wonderful and amazing!! You should definitely go bathe in champagne. I can't wait until the day I don't have to deal with diapers anymore (I use cloth, so at least I don't have to buy them all the time...but I do have to wash them all the time).

My daughter (2.5 years) has been daytime potty trained for months now. I can't figure out how to do naptime and bedtime, though. I should probably just stop using the pull-ups at naptime, because she's *usually* dry when she gets up...but she's always wet in the morning, no matter how many times we make her pee before she goes to bed. The thought of waking her up to go pee before we go to bed sounds awful to me, but maybe that's what I need to do? Or do I just stop putting the nighttime pull-up on her and see what happens? Anyone have any suggestions?
My recent post Poop.
3 replies · active 592 weeks ago
I should add that I have a 7-month old, which is why I will still have to deal with diapers for a while...just not as many.
My recent post Poop.
Thank you! Yeah, I'd stop using the nap time pull ups if I were you. Nighttime is tricky. Our first ALWAYS was wet in the morning, and we were scared he'd constantly pee the bed if we took them away, which is why we waited so long. But as soon as we did, he'd stay dry all night, so he was just using them because he had them on, basically. Then after we took them away, we'd usually wake him once in the night to go to the bathroom (for another couple of months), but looking back, we probably didn't need to do that. He would have been fine. Get an under pad for her bed and cross your fingers?
If she's in a crib though and can't easily get out to go to the bathroom, then maybe keep the night ones on for a bit...
Good luck!
Thank you! She's in a regular bed, so hopefully she would get up if she has to go. I'm willing to give no pull-ups a try, I just have to get my husband on board now! :)
My recent post Poop.
I had heard all of that "second child is so easy" reassurance, and so I was ready to skate out of diapers with my second daughter early on. She - was - awful. She refused to use the toilet. Lots of accidents. There was no amount of bribing, cajoling, or threatening that I could do to get this kid to stop. And we were moving cross country in a week, which I didn't want her to do in diapers, but also didn't want her to do in a pee-soaked car seat.

In comes Grandma. She came to help us do the cross-country drive. Grandma says, "You're a big girl, you don't go potty in your pants anymore."

And that was it. She didn't. WHAT THE HELL!? And why didn't grandma say that, oh, six months or so earlier when I still had some hair left and a less progressed form of wine-induced liver disease??
My recent post Disneyland, but Cheaper
2 replies · active 591 weeks ago
Ha why do grandmas have the special power? My mom does the same thing with my kid and its so frustrating!
That's so annoyingly awesome!! My mom has tried that with mine and it didn't work, so I'm glad it worked for someone! Now go take some milk thistle for your wine-induced liver disease!
So, you know I'm a pre-k teacher right? Well my experience is that if you don't push it, they just do it. No (or few accidents) so you know what? that's totally my plan since conception. My hubby had other plans, luckily just before Animal turned two, the hubby said "you know he's a smart guy, let's just wait till he wants to use the potty".

oh, he's in preschool, so lots of ops to see what all the other kids are doing. also very helpful I have found. You know what is not helpful, fucking pull ups. they are a big waste of time and money. They're just diapers and your kid knows it.

Lastly my mom (at two) took all diapers away and and promised cold showers in exchange for any accidents. It worked for 3 children, only one of which received a cold shower.
My recent post Running Again
1 reply · active 591 weeks ago
The only good thing about pull-ups is ease of use when they are actually going in the potty!
I totally agree about the not pushing it thing, but that's why our first was in diapers for so long! I think, like with everything, some things work for some kids and not for others.
Holy shit, that's a stone-cold (pun intended!) method that your mom used, but sounds like it was effective! :-)
I have 4.......my oldest is 5 and the only girl; then I have 3 1/2, 1 1/2, and 4 month old boys, so I've got at least 2 more years of diaps to look forward to. However, with Riley it was pretty easy. I started when I was on maternity leave with my first boy. She had lierally just turned 2. We went for the naked on bottom in the house method. This worked after 2 accidents the first day.....only worked for 2 weeks. A couple months after that, both kids went to daycare for the first time and Riley just didn't want the other kids seeing her getting a diaper changed so she went in with training underwear one day and never had an accident again. The oldest boy, though, Brody.....oh god, awful. We tried potty training last summer when he was 2 1/2, Which is how we discovered he had a pelvic hernia. Awesome. He was terrified of the potty. Finally got him trained this summer while I was on maternity leave with the youngest. We tried everything. What worked for him was setting a timer to go off every 20 minutes for a week, then the second week it was 30 minutes. THIS WAS A NIGHTMARE. He went pee EVERY SINGLE TIME. I was terrified he'd always have to go that often, but hey, since mid-August, he had only one accident, and it was in front of the toilet because his snap was stuck on his jeans. After the 2 weeks we only had night time diapers for another week and 1/2. So it sucked, but I'd do it again. And with the other 2 I may have to...
1 reply · active 591 weeks ago
Yikes! Good luck with the last two!
This post was sent to me by my daughter to point out that I always go to far for Christmas decorations and it only wears me out and no one really cares. It worked. Enjoy the holiday and you loved ones. Then you don

Post a new comment

Comments by